The 18 Myths
An overview of the core arguments dismantled within the book.
Myth #1: Fight Against Hate for Good
— Why the 'Fight Hate' Framework Fails Jewish Advocacy
Myth #2: Jews Must Be Treated Same as Marginalized Groups
— Why Grievance Hierarchies Contradict Jewish and American Principles
Myth #3: Social Media Profits From Hate
— Misunderstanding the Role of Technology in Antisemitic Discourse
Myth #4: Antisemitism Means Democracy is Declining
— Separating Antisemitic Incidents from Democratic Health
Myth #5: Jews Should Feel Unsafe from Hate Speech
— Why Fear-Based Advocacy Undermines Jewish Confidence
Myth #6: Antisemitism is Wrong Because It's a Conspiracy Theory
— Why Moral Clarity Requires Better Arguments
Myth #7: Antisemitism Is 'On the Rise'
— Questioning the Evidence Behind Crisis Narratives
Myth #8: Antizionism Is Always Antisemitism
— The Importance of Precise Definitions in Advocacy
Myth #9: We Should Protect Jews of Color
— How Racialized Frameworks Fragment Jewish Identity
Myth #10: Fight Extremism as Part of Fighting Antisemitism
— How the Extremism Framework Distorts Threat Assessment
Myth #11: Form Allies to Fight Antisemitism
— The Strategic Failure of Transactional Coalition Politics
Myth #12: Jews Should Be Included in Ethnic Studies
— Why the Ethnic Studies Curriculum Threatens Jewish Students
Myth #13: Fight Islamophobia as Part of Fighting Antisemitism
— How a Rhetorical Pairing Undermines Moral Clarity
Myth #14: Fight Anti-LGBTQ+ Sentiment as Part of Fighting Antisemitism
— When Coalition Demands Override Communal Deliberation
Myth #15: Same Strategy Against Legal and Illegal Antisemitism
— The Critical Distinction Between Protected Speech and Illegal Discrimination
Myth #16: Fight Antisemitism Equally on Left and Right
— Why Symmetrical Condemnation Is Reckless, Not Principled
Myth #17: Condemning Antisemitism Addresses Antizionism
— How Ritual Condemnation Protects Antizionists
Myth #18: Legacy Jewish Organizations Speak for the Jewish People
— The Myth of Institutional Representation